As mentioned before, determination of the moment at which human life begins is pivotal in stem cell debates. Ensoulment is defined as the time when the entity becomes a human being, based on many religions' perspectives, although the moment when the soul arrives is long disputed.
Judaism considers the extracorporeal embryo in the preimplantation stage as genetic
material, so stem cell research is permissible according to most branches of Judaism
(Hinman, 2009; Childress, 2004; Ohara, 2003; Bioethics Advisory commission, 2000). A human embryo is not considered as sacred until the fourth month of pregnancy, according to most Jewish scholars (Pompe et al, 2005). Owing to this fact, research on stem cell and human embryos is allowed in this period.
In Christianity, while the current dominant belief is that ensoulment occurs at the moment
of conception, the Roman Catholic theologian, Thomas Aquinas, believed that the soul arrives around the third month of pregnancy (quickening). St. Augustine believed that personhood begins with ensoulment at forty days of gestation, in accordance with Aristotle's and Talmudic scholars' views (Balint, 2001). Although this opinion was accepted by Popes innocent III (1211 AD) and Gregory XIII (1550 AD), increased use of abortion in the
18th century led to a change in the Church's thinking. As a result, Pope Pius IX decreed that ensoulment occurs at fertilization, and his viewpoint was followed by the Orthodox Church (Balint, 2001).
Currently, the Catholic Church believes personhood begins at conception (Daar et al., 2004). Despite strong opposition of Catholics to stem cell research, Protestants have a wider range of views (Childress, 2004; Ohara, 2003; Bioethics Advisory commission, 2000). Less conservative Protestant Christians support stem cell research at least before the development of the primitive streak at 14 days after fertilization (Fadel, 2007).
Most Muslim thinkers accept embryonic stem cell research (Childress, 2004; Ohara, 2003; Bioethics Advisory commission, 2000), although there are obstacles to the research in some Islamic countries (Ilkilic & Ertin, 2010). According to Islamic teachings, decisions on stem cell research and cloning research should be based on advantages and limitations. Considering inevitable consequences of reproductive cloning, it is prohibited by many Muslim religious authorities; however, stem cell research and cloning for therapeutic purposes is sometimes permissible with precautions in pre-ensoulment stages of fetus development (Larijani & Zahedi, 2004). Most branches of Islam consider ensoulment as the moment when the entity would have a full value of human beings, though the moral singularity of humans occurs at implantation.
Holy Quran depicts the different stages of human development in the womb in verses 12-
14 of the chapter (Sura) of Al-Mumenoon (the Believers). Based on these verses and some other Islamic resources, it is accepted by Muslim scholars that ensoulment takes place at
120 days after conception (Aksoy, 2005; Morrison and Khademhosseini, 2011). It is noteworthy that in Islam human embryonic life is entitled to respect at any stages even before the breathing of spirit into the fetus (Fadel, 2007); however, the respect grows as the weeks pass until ensoulment when the child deserves the full respect of human being. As Ilkilic and Ertin (2010) state “…the ensoulment gives the embryo an exceptional moral status, which is decisive for the ethical assessment of any medical intervention affecting the embryo.” So, experimental activities and therapeutic uses of stem cells are permissible before ensoulment with necessary precautions when they are justifiable based on Islamic principles such as the public interest. Looking for scientific advancements and seeking new treatments for human disorders may also apply to justify the use of human embryonic stem cells (Fadel, 2007).
The source of stem cells has been considered by Islamic scholars in issuing fatwa (religious decree) on permissibility of stem cell research. For instance, the scholars in the confereence of the Muslim World League’s Islamic Jurisprudence Council held in Mecca in 2003 issued that the use of stem cells for therapy or scientific research is permitted as long as the cells’ sources are permissible. Adults who consent, placenta or umbilical cord blood, excess fertilized eggs produced during the course of IVF and spontaneously aborted embryos are some acceptable resources, and intentionally aborted fetuses are forbidden to be used as a source for stem cells (Fadel, 2007, citation of Muslim Word League, 2003).
Monday, 15 July 2013
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment